Settle The Debate Once And For All - Team Pumpkin Pie Or Team Sweet Potato Pie?

thriller screen shot
NBC Bay Area

Hands down, dessert is one of the best parts of the Thanksgiving meal! We think most can agree. But, the one thing that can make or break any Thanksgiving dessert table is the WRONG pie! Y'all know exactly what we're talking about. You invited your white friends over, cuz y'all are just mad cool like that...and they offered to bring one of granny's homemade pies. Sounds good! The turkey, dressing, and fixings were on point! Then dessert time rolls around, you see the pie, and go in for the kill. It looks like sweet potato, smells like sweet potato, you go in for that first bite and you STOP -- IT'S PUMPKIN! What the.....

Which one of you committed this crime - who bought PUMPKIN pie? This pie has got to go and so does the perpetrator who disrespected the dessert!

Now, we suspect this might have happened on the flip side of things if you invited your black friends over to your Aunt Suzy's turkey day dinner. You ended up with sweet potato but we already know - you were expecting pumpkin.

So let's settle this once and for all... Are you team pumpkin or sweet potato?

Here's how some of our favorite celebs weighed in:

Comedian Gary Owen knows first hand, you do NOT disrespect sweet potato pie by calling it pumpkin - the two are distinctly different! Don't slip up and make this mistake -- it's the first in a series that can result in black card repossession. 

Yes - we went there y'all. 

Sweet potato - 1  Pumpkin - 0


If it's one thing you can always count on a black mama for, is having a sweet potato pie on her table on Thanksgiving, and 9/10 it'll probably be homemade! Mike Epps knows the deal, y'all better recognize.

Sweet potato - 2  Pumpkin - 0


Even comedian Chris Spencer makes a compelling case in the great pie debate! Listen, y'all can't let your white friends bring pumpkin pie to dinner. Husbands and wives are included in this! It's not just them we'll spend the evening giving the side eye to - they are YOUR responsibility! So while everyone's over there NOT eating sweet potato pie...they will be subtracting them points away from your black card. Be careful!

Sweet potato 3  Pumpkin - 0

Bonus:

Okay, we can't promise that any pie will make you sound like Mr. James Wright here, let alone Patti LaBelle, but you tell us the last time a slice of pumpkin pie got a reaction like THIS!

Don't worry...we'll wait.

Couldn't find anything? ..... We thought so!

Sweet potato - 4  Pumpkin - 0

Listen, if there was an official list for reasons to revoke a black card, ADMITTING TO LOVING PUMPKIN PIE would be smack dead at the top! Don't let this happen to you! Your membership is valued - but tough decisions have to be made y'all.

So settle the debate for us, comment and tell us which team you're repping - Sweet potato or Pumpkin?

Annd... just in case you're on team pumpkin and this post has convinced you to jump ship, we'll leave this recipe for Auntie Fee's sweet potato pie right here.

Happy Thanksgiving fam!


Click here to get alerts of the latest stories